How to get the exact same output from mysqldump as mysqladmin/backup

Question

On a very important Windows server we use a scheduled task set up by the mysqladmin utility to back up our critical data.

I'd like to use the simpler mysqldump command, but I want to ensure that the output is the same. Presumably mysqladmin and mysqldump both share a common core dumping component, so for any given setting in mysqladmin I ought to be able to find a configuration for mysqldump which produce the exact same output.

But how?

At the moment I am resorting to trial & error - but is there a better way to do it?

Answer 1

MySQL Administrator does not actually use the same core dumping ability as mysqldump. For some reason, it was reimplemented (and generally worse off than mysqldump uses).

So I would recommend you pick the options you most desire and use those in mysqldump.

Answer 2

I would first dump some short tables with mysqladmin and the same tables with mysqldump. Then I would check the differences and find the appropriate options to use using the mysqldump manual.