You said that you are trying to use ruby 2.1.1. but your log show us ruby 1.8.7.
With that in mind, it seems that you have 2 rubies installed on your machine... ruby 1.8.7 installed by homebrew, and ruby 2.1.1 installed by rvm.
And apparently you also have jekyll installed on ruby 1.8.7 gemset...
So, I recommend you to do that:
gem uninstall jekyll
rvm use 2.1.1
gem install jekyll