As we all no doubt know, the ISO C standard (and C++ as well, I think, though I'm more interested on the C side) allows three underlying representations of signed numbers:

  • two's complement;
  • ones' complement; and
  • sign/magnitude.

Wikipedia's entry states that sign/magnitude is used on the IBM 7090 from the 60s, and that ones' complement is used by the PDP-1, CDC 160A and UNIVAC 1100, all of which date back to the 60s as well.

Are there any other implementations of C (or underlying hardware) with these alternative representations, that have come out a little more recently than fifty years ago (and what are they)?

It seems a little wasteful to keep something in a standard for machines no longer in existence.

有帮助吗?

解决方案

The most recent example I can find is the UNISYS 2200 series, based on UNIVAC, with ones-complement arithmetic. The various models were produced between 1986 and 1997 but the OS was still in active development as late as 2015. They also had a C compiler, as seen here.

It seems likely that they may still be in use today.

其他提示

I don't have any conclusive evidence that none exist, but I've never seen one. To my knowledge, all non-twos-complement hardware was obsolete long before C was standardized.

Perhaps the best way to gather evidence would be to look for conflicting requirements and other outright bugs in the standard connected to non-twos-complement systems. If no such implementation has ever been created, it's likely there are oversights in the specification that would become apparent when somebody actually tries to make one.

许可以下: CC-BY-SA归因
不隶属于 StackOverflow
scroll top