Changing the JOIN from INNER JOIN to LEFT JOIN did the job:
SELECT tblTrades.Tick, IIf([tblTrades].[vd_off]>Now(),[qselSumPastDivs_vd].[SumOfBBG_Div_Forecast],[qselSumOfPastDivs].[SumOfBBG_Div_Forecast]) AS DivLevel2
FROM ((tblTrades INNER JOIN tblBbgDivData ON tblTrades.Tick = tblBbgDivData.Tick) LEFT JOIN qselSumOfPastDivs ON tblTrades.Tick = qselSumOfPastDivs.Tick) LEFT JOIN qselSumPastDivs_vd ON tblTrades.Tick = qselSumPastDivs_vd.Tick
GROUP BY tblTrades.Tick, IIf([tblTrades].[vd_off]>Now(),[qselSumPastDivs_vd].[SumOfBBG_Div_Forecast],[qselSumOfPastDivs].[SumOfBBG_Div_Forecast]);