How to add small messages in shelve in perforce?

Question

I usually use GIT for my local versioning. The server uses perforce. Although i have a good set of small commits in git and i like it so that i can see the messages with commits. This helps in recollecting a lot of steps taken.

But then for the server, i just keep shelving the file to the same pending changelist in the perforce. I do not revert back the files. This is the option given in perforce client.

How can i save my changes with the messages ?

Am i required to use something other than shelve ?

Answer 1

It sounds like you should be making multiple shelves, not updating a single existing shelf.

Alternatively, create a branch for your work, and submit each incremental change as a separate changelist. Since you're working in a separate branch, your work isn't affecting others until you integrate the work from your branch back to the parent codeline.

In general, I find that as soon as I want to track more than a single set of changes (i.e., more than a single git commit), it's time to create a branch.

Perforce has a variety of features that can be used efficiently in this case; contact your Perforce administrator at your site for assistance.

Answer 2

Bryan's answer is probably the most straightforward option. You could also look into using P4 Sandbox, which is basically a different way of accomplishing the same thing.