Installing PHP Pear packages via Ansible with idempotency

Question

I'm currently installing Pear packages for PHP with Ansible like so:

- name: Add Phergie PEAR channel.
  command: pear channel-discover pear.phergie.org
  ignore_errors: yes

- name: Install Phergie and related plugins.
  command: pear install pear.phergie.org/{{ item }}
  with_items:
  - Phergie
  - Phergie_Plugin_AltNick
  ignore_errors: yes

The ignore_errors is required because pear always reports an error when running a command that's been run/completed successfully before (like:

TASK: [Add Phergie PEAR channel.] ********************************************* 
failed: [10.31.9.210] => {"changed": true, "cmd": ["pear", "channel-discover", "pear.phergie.org"], "delta": "0:00:01.089340", "end": "2013-12-27 10:16:25.640083", "item": "", "rc": 1, "start": "2013-12-27 10:16:24.550743"}
stdout: Channel "pear.phergie.org" is already initialized
...ignoring

TASK: [Install Phergie and related plugins.] ********************************** 
failed: [10.31.9.210] => (item=Phergie) => {"changed": true, "cmd": ["pear", "install", "pear.phergie.org/Phergie"], "delta": "0:00:03.698780", "end": "2013-12-27 10:16:30.337371", "item": "Phergie", "rc": 1, "start": "2013-12-27 10:16:26.638591"}
stdout: phergie/Phergie is already installed and is the same as the released version 2.1.0
install failed
...ignoring
failed: [10.31.9.210] => (item=Phergie_Plugin_AltNick) => {"changed": true, "cmd": ["pear", "install", "pear.phergie.org/Phergie_Plugin_AltNick"], "delta": "0:00:01.779589", "end": "2013-12-27 10:16:33.231524", "item": "Phergie_Plugin_AltNick", "rc": 1, "start": "2013-12-27 10:16:31.451935"}
stdout: phergie/Phergie_Plugin_AltNick is already installed and is the same as the released version 2.1.0
install failed
...ignoring

Is there a better (more idempotent) way to run pear commands, and not have to scroll through a bunch of big, red ignored errors?

Answer 1

Starting from Ansible v2 there is an extra module for managing PEAR extensions: http://docs.ansible.com/ansible/pear_module.html

So now you can just use:

- pear: name=Net_URL2 state=latest

Answer 2

Okay, so after playing around with the changed_when property a bit, I finally found a solution to this (was testing on a different playbook, where I was installing drush instead of Phergie, but the problem/solution is exactly the same:

Playbook:

- name: Setup drush PEAR channel.
  command: pear channel-discover pear.drush.org
  register: channel_result
  environment: proxy_env
  changed_when: "'initialized' not in channel_result.stdout"
  # TODO: This will always error out the first time it's run.
  failed_when: "'already initialized' not in channel_result.stdout"

- name: Install drush.
  command: pear install drush/drush
  register: drush_result
  environment: proxy_env
  changed_when: "'installed' not in drush_result.stdout"
  failed_when: "'6.2.0.0' not in drush_result.stdout"

New output from Ansible:

TASK: [Setup drush PEAR channel.] ********************************************* 
ok: [midwesternmac]

TASK: [Install drush.] ******************************************************** 
ok: [midwesternmac]

So now in the summary, instead of reporting an extra 'changed' for every server and every pear command, Ansible only reports 'changed' iff there was a change. More documentation (though sparse) on changed_when and failed_when (which require Ansible >= 1.3) is available here: Error Handling In Playbooks

Answer 3

- name: Install drush.
  command: pear upgrade drush/drush

Not sure if using 'upgrade' instead of 'install' translates well to your leading channel-discovery command