The reason for encapsulation [closed]

Question

Closed. This question does not meet Stack Overflow guidelines. It is not currently accepting answers.

---

This question does not appear to be about programming within the scope defined in the help center.

Closed 8 years ago.

Improve this question

I've read some things about this, I even found similar question, but it didn't really answer this. For me it seems that privatizing something only makes my life so much harder when I need to find a private variable in a class to use it elsewhere. So what is would the problem be if everything was public? Would it somehow slow the program itself?

Answer 1

You must consider the maintainability of the code. Accessing all the variables everywhere in your solution is good only if you are the only one in the project and you will be the only one that maintain and use the code. If someone else's entered into project and do completely different things they will be able to access your methods/variables and set the things to unexpected variables. You should think as a OOP design and design your classes like that.

Answer 2

FYI I don't believe you are supposed to ask discussion-based questions like this on SO... But the simplistic answer is this: don't limit your thinking to the logic of the code. We all know there are ten thousand ways to accomplish the same thing. You can probably rewrite a bunch of your code to avoid encapsulation. However, data encapsulation provides a few benefits when you start working on larger projects or with larger teams that go beyond just writing functional code:

(1) organization by concept: if you're coding a bike you would code a class for the wheel, a class for the frame, a class for the handlebars, etc., and you'd know where to go to resolve an issue, perhaps even after months of time away from the code;

(2) separation of implementation and interface: you can tell the world about your public interface and handle the actual implementation privately, so people don't have to know how things work in your code, they just know that it works, like a black box; and if later you have to change your private implementation you can do so freely as long as the public interface still works;

(3) simplification for humans: remember, humans read your code, so would you like to slam them with every bit of data and logic in your project? that would just make for a bunch of angry programmers.

So that's a gentle introduction to encapsulation.

Answer 3

This comes from the fact that, a class should not expose its members directly but must provide a proxy through which the members must be accessed. (Like getters/setters or Properties)

See this question for more info: Why it is recommended to declare instance variables as private?