I got it and here's how I went about it:
First I got all the rows, then...
echo 'Total rows in table: '.$j.'<br />';
$twentyfive = floor($j*.25);
$fifteen = floor($j*.15);
$ten = floor($j*.1);
echo $ten.' '.$fifteen.' '.$twentyfive.'<br /><br />';
$topten=0;
while($topten < $ten && $percentile_row2 = mysql_fetch_array($percentile_result2)){
$change = "UPDATE Players SET " . $column['field'] ."=concat(" . $column['field'] . ",'%') WHERE user_id='" . $percentile_row2['user_id'] . "'";
$wpdb->get_results($change);
echo '<strong>in top 10%</strong> - '.$percentile_row2['field_1'].' - '.$percentile_row2['user_id'].'<br />';
$topten++;
}
And so on for the other percentiles. All the echoes were just to track it.