I don't think there is a way to pass *kwargs like this from the template using the built-in url template tag.
There are two ways you can do this, one is to create two separate urls and pass the decision as a kwarg to the view:
urls.py
url(r'^judge_request_cut/(?P<gslug>[\w-]+)$',
group_judge_request,
kwargs={'decision': 0},
name='group_judge_request_cut'),
url(r'^judge_request_keep/(?P<gslug>[\w-]+)$',
group_judge_request,
kwargs={'decision': 1},
name='group_judge_request_keep'),
template
{% for asking in requested %}
<a href={% url 'group_judge_request_cut' group_profile.slug decision=0 %}>Cut {{ asking.user.username }}</a>
<a href={% url 'group_judge_request_keep' group_profile.slug decision=1 %}>Keep {{ asking.user.username }}</a>
{% endfor %}
Or you could pass the integer as a parameter:
urls.py
url(r'^judge_request/(?P<gslug>[\w-]+)/(?P<decision>\d{1})$',
group_judge_request,
name='group_judge_request'),
template
{% for asking in requested %}
<a href={% url 'group_judge_request' group_profile.slug 0 %}>Cut {{ asking.user.username }}</a>
<a href={% url 'group_judge_request' group_profile.slug 1 %}>Keep {{ asking.user.username }}</a>
{% endfor %}