You are grabbing the first one. You need to use the item that is being passed in like so:
protected void repRunResults_ItemDataBound(object sender, RepeaterItemEventArgs e)
{
//capture current context.
Repeater repRunResults = (Repeater)sender;
Label laMessage = e.Item.FindControl("laMessage"); //<-- Used e.Item here
DSScatterData.RunResultsRow rRunResults = (DSScatterData.RunResultsRow)((DataRowView)(e.Item.DataItem)).Row;
//show message if needed.
int iTotal = this.GetTotal(m_eStatus, rRunResults.MaxIterations, rRunResults.TargetLimit);
if(iTotal == 100)
{
laMessage.Text = "The computed total is 100.";
}
else
{
laMessage.Text = "The computed total is NOT 100.";
}
}