Clojure: function composition at runtime
-
21-12-2019 - |
Question
Problem:
Suppose I have a set of functions f_1 ... f_n that I want to compose at runtime, such that I get for example:
(f_a (f_b (f_c) (f_d)) (f_e))
Therefore I need the types of the parameters and the return value of each function in order to know, which functions I can plug into each other.
First Attempt: Annotate each function
(defn foo [n f]
^{:params [Number clojure.lang.Fn]
:return String}
(do stuff with f and n, return a string))
I don't like this approach because of obvious reasons, such as if I wanted to use clojure.core as the set of functions I would have to annotate every function, which wouldn't be very desirable.
Questions
How would you attempt to solve this problem?
Could core.typed help me with that?
Solution
I do similar things when composing the search query to pass to solr and use a map for the arguments to all the functions and have them all return a map with whatever changes the function decided to make contained in the map, and everything else returned unchanged. So in short i would:
- use a map for the input and output of every function
- core.typed is not helpful because everything is a map
- prismatic.schema is very helpful because you can use it to know what keys are required and to write tests that validate the structure of these maps.
Projects/people with more of an inclination to statically typed functional languages will likely turn to monads in cases like this because they are a powerful tool for describing composition in a type safe way.