What to tell a manager who tells your estimates are too much for a genuine task [duplicate]
-
08-10-2020 - |
italiano
english
français
española
中国
日本の
العربية
Deutsch
한국어
Português
RussianQuestion
My manager keeps complaining that the estimates we have come up with are too much for the customer — every time he asks us to think like a customer and see whether the estimate is valid, but my point is that even though we somehow finish the project on time, lots of issues might creep up in the project. Apart from this, I am the only developer for this project, and he puts most of the blame on me; be it design, bugs or any other discrepancy in the project.
I am not sure if I am doing anything wrong, or is software engineering a field with no bugs where everything should be perfect? Is my manager is wrong? Can anyone explain?
Solution
Your manager is probably under pressure to justify your time estimates, thus the friction. This kind of friction is part of the work environment, there are lots of books, classes, coaching sessions available that will teach you how to interact with different people and personality types so you can do your job.
More importantly for the customer ( and for your own ease of mind ), have you established a track record for the effort it takes to deliver a project, or talked with others in the industry about your time estimates? A good way to approach this kind of problem is to find a senior programmer who can give you some guidance on how long things should take so you get a sense of how you are doing relative to industry expectations. Once you have a sense for how long things 'should' take, you can apply your soft skills to the task of negotiating with your manager for more time as appropriate.
The customer may expect things better, faster, and cheaper, but in general they only get two of those three things. I've had potential customers say things like, "We have X budget and we want to become an online leader in our space." Just because they want it does not mean it will happen. Things take as long as they take.
Of course, if you really want to excel, find a way to do the same work better, faster, and cheaper. Like I said, mostly that is not what the customer gets, but if you can do it, you will get props from your manager and your customers. Automation, improved tools, better processes - these are your friends.
OTHER TIPS
Q: "What to tell a manager who tells your estimates are too much for a genuine task"
A: "I am starting at new job in x weeks. Who should I hand over the project to?"
Estimation is difficult to get right. The variations are often high. In my experience, breaking down tasks helps a lot to estimate and plan well. This will help your manager see why your estimates are what they are.
Try estimating in Story points at a high level (And estimate in man-hours on specific subjects within the sprint). This over a period of time will give you the velocity, which is the Story points achievable over a sprint or release. Then as we add stories, we add the Story points estimates. This activity might not be suited for a one member team though.
Deliver something to customer and get feedback from the customer. This will help you to identify early a design issue.
