Get a random subset from a set in F#

Question

I am trying to think of an elegant way of getting a random subset from a set in F#

Any thoughts on this?

Perhaps this would work: say we have a set of 2^x elements and we need to pick a subset of y elements. Then if we could generate an x sized bit random number that contains exactly y 2ⁿ powers we effectively have a random mask with y holes in it. We could keep generating new random numbers until we get the first one satisfying this constraint but is there a better way?

Answer 1

If you don't want to convert to an array you could do something like this. This is O(n*m) where m is the size of the set.

open System

let rnd = Random(0);
let set = Array.init 10 (fun i -> i) |> Set.of_array

let randomSubSet n set =
    seq { 
        let i = set |> Set.to_seq |> Seq.nth (rnd.Next(set.Count))
        yield i
        yield! set |> Set.remove i 
        }
    |> Seq.take n
    |> Set.of_seq

let result = set |> randomSubSet 3 

for x in result do
    printfn "%A" x    

Answer 2

Agree with @JohannesRossel. There's an F# shuffle-an-array algorithm here you can modify suitably. Convert the Set into an array, and then loop until you've selected enough random elements for the new subset.

Answer 3

Not having a really good grasp of F# and what might be considered elegant there, you could just do a shuffle on the list of elements and select the first y. A Fisher-Yates shuffle even helps you in this respect as you also only need to shuffle y elements.

Answer 4

rnd must be out of subset function.

let rnd = new Random()
let rec subset xs = 
    let removeAt n xs = ( Seq.nth (n-1) xs, Seq.append (Seq.take (n-1) xs) (Seq.skip n xs) )
    match xs with 
    | [] -> []
    | _ -> let (rem, left) = removeAt (rnd.Next( List.length xs ) + 1) xs
           let next = subset (List.of_seq left)
           if rnd.Next(2) = 0 then rem :: next else next

Answer 5

Do you mean a random subset of any size?

For the case of a random subset of a specific size, there's a very elegant answer here:

Select N random elements from a List<T> in C#

Here it is in pseudocode:

RandomKSubset(list, k):
  n = len(list)
  needed = k
  result = {}
  for i = 0 to n:
    if rand() < needed / (n-i)
      push(list[i], result)
      needed--
  return result

Answer 6

Using Seq.fold to construct using lazy evaluation random sub-set:

let rnd = new Random()

let subset2 xs = let insertAt n xs x = Seq.concat [Seq.take n xs; seq [x]; Seq.skip n xs]
                 let randomInsert xs = insertAt (rnd.Next( (Seq.length xs) + 1 )) xs
                 xs |> Seq.fold randomInsert Seq.empty |> Seq.take (rnd.Next( Seq.length xs ) + 1)