Question

I'm developing a piece of a system that basically migrates data from one set of tables to another set. Everything works fine, but I've decided to employ transactions instead of just failing on things that are partially completed. (That is, if some exception occurs, I want to rollback instead of having partial data migrated.)

I have a service (in the 3-tier architecture way, not web) which begins a transaction on the data access layer. The data context is shared in the data access class which contains many methods. Those methods use various LINQ-to-SQL techniques to update/insert/delete. All the LINQ-to-SQL "selects" are within CompiledQueries.

The "BeginTransaction" method starts a transaction like this:

Public Sub BeginTransaction() Implements ITransactionalQueriesBase.BeginTransaction
    Me.Context.Connection.Open()
    Me.Context.Transaction = Context.Connection.BeginTransaction()
    IsInTransaction = True
End Sub

Basically, I have written a test which starts a transaction, inserts into a table, and then attempts to retrieve the value that was just inserted, all during the transaction. I did this because I wanted to assert that the insert method actually tries to insert. Then, during the test I would rollback, then test to ensure that the newly inserted value is not actually committed to the table. The test looks something like this:

<TestMethod()>
    Public Sub FacilityService_Can_Rollback_A_Transaction()
        faciService.BeginTransaction()

        Dim devApp = UnitTestHelper.CreateDevelopmentApplication(devService.GetDevelopmentType("NEWFACI").ID, 1, 1, 1, 1)

        Dim devInsertRes = devService.InsertDevelopmentApplication(devApp)

        Assert.IsTrue(devInsertRes.ReturnValue > 0)

        For Each dir1 In devInsertRes.Messages
            Assert.Fail(dir1)
        Next

        Dim migrationResult = faciService.ProcessNewFacilityDevelopment(devInsertRes.ReturnValue)
        Assert.IsTrue(migrationResult.ReturnValue.InsertResult)

        Dim faciRetrieval1 = faciService.GetFacilityByID(migrationResult.ReturnValue.FacilityID)
        Assert.IsNotNull(faciRetrieval1.ReturnValue)

        faciService.Rollback()

        Dim faciRetrieval2 = faciService.GetFacilityByID(migrationResult.ReturnValue.FacilityID)
        Assert.IsNull(faciRetrieval2.ReturnValue)
    End Sub

So, to my problem...

When the test gets to the "faciRetrieval1" step, it stays there for about 30-60 seconds before moving on. I'm not sure why this is happening. If I run the same queries in a transaction within SSMS it happens instantly. Does anyone have any ideas? The database is a SQL Server 2008 SP1 (R2?).

Was it helpful?

Solution

I figured out that if you have a data context using a transaction, any other data context appears to not be able to select from another context of the same type.

I ended up fixing it by using the same context throughout every select/update/delete while a transaction was happening.

Licensed under: CC-BY-SA with attribution
Not affiliated with StackOverflow
scroll top