How do I stop DVD player from autoplaying?

Question

When I insert a movie DVD into my USB superdrive, the DVD player starts. I want it to stop doing that.

I've tried the following to disable this behaviour:

• System Preferences -> CDs & DVDs -> When you insert a video DVD: set to Ignore (actually moved all of them to Ignore)
• DVD player -> Preferences -> unchecked "Start playing disc" for when DVD player opens and when a disc is inserted.

Neither of these made a difference; insert the disc and the DVD player still starts playing it. Any other options?

Answer 1

You might have more success using RCDefaultApp (freeware, old but still functional) if only because it shows a few more choices of precisely what to ignore.