Handle exception on service startup

Question

I'm writing a series of Windows services. I want them to fail if errors are thrown during startup (in OnStart() method). I had assumed that merely throwing an error in OnStart() would do this, but I'm finding that instead it "Starts" and presents me with a message stating "The service has started, but is inactive. Is this correct?" (Paraphrase). How do I handle the error so it actually fails to start the service?

Answer 1

if you are running .NET 2.0 or higher, you can use ServiceBase.Stop to stop the service from OnStart. Otherwise call Stop from a new thread.

ref [devnewsgroups] (http://www.devnewsgroups.net/group/microsoft.public.dotnet.framework/topic50404.aspx)

(news group gone)

Answer 2

If the main thing you want is for the Services window to report that there was an error, from what I've tried (.net 3.5 on Windows 7), the only way to do this is by setting the ExitCode. I recommend setting it to 13816, since this results in the message, "An unknown error has occurred." See the windows error codes.

The sample below accomplishes three things. 1 - setting ExitCode results in a useful message for the end-user. It doesn't affect the Windows Application log but does include a message in the System log. 2 - Calling Stop results in a "Service successfully stopped" message in the Application log. 3 - throwing the exception results in a useful log entry in the Application log.

protected override void OnStart(string[] args) {

  try {
    // Start your service
  }
  catch (Exception ex) {
    // Log exception
    this.ExitCode = 13816;
    this.Stop();
    throw;
  }

}

Answer 3

Move all of your startup logic to a separate method, and Throw exceptions (or call OnStop) from that seperate method.

OnStart has some oddities when starting up. I have found that if OnStart() has no more than one line in it, then I dont get the "The service started and then stopped.Some services stop automatically if they have no work to do" message, and thrown exceptions will terminate the process and log to the app event log.

Also with the seperate startup method, you can use a technique like this to debug it without attaching. http://www.codeproject.com/KB/dotnet/DebugWinServices.aspx