Finish proof with false hypothesis in Coq
-
19-06-2021 - |
Question
So I have a false hypothesis in a subgoal. It's an equality between different constructors. How do I finish the subgoal?
H: List.Not_Empty Bit.Bit Bit.Zero (List.Empty Bit.Bit) = List.Empty Bit.Bit
Solution
This doesn't look like the Coq List I'm used to from the standard library, so it will be hard to help you without knowing the definitions of List.Not_Empty and List.Empty. If I guess correctly that List.Empty
stands for nil
and List.Not_empty
stands for cons
, then it's just a matter of showing that the two constructors are not equal. You can for instance do:
congruence.
or simply:
inversion H.
However, if it's something more involved, these two might fail. So you'd want to either:
SearchAbout List.Not_Empty.
to see if lemmas exist about it, or to:
unfold List.Not_Empty, List.Empty in H.
to unfold definitions and work out the details (possibly saving this subproof as a lemma if it does not exist, as it seems useful).