How are you ensuring the bat is closing the conductive circuit from the phone to your hand? I'd suggest copious use of the material used to make gloves touchscreen friendly. Silver-threaded nylon is recommended here: http://www.howtogeek.com/130477/diy-touch-screen-mod-makes-regular-gloves-smartphone-friendly/
UPDATE: Oh, you might need to amplify the very tiny current that the bat will experience so it can travel all the way to your hand. I'm not an electrician but a portable car battery attached to the bat via the same thread should do the trick.