Turns out you need to use --revision-range
with the git commits for before and after your change. E.g.
post-review --revision-range=f17f771:f5b67e3
Notice that I'm using a truncated value for the commit numbers. Their actual values are f5b67e3978ec0348d33672ba79215fe887709bed and f17f7714f7e6c92fafb03bbfa3d7fefdb3295039. However, I got the range from a git pull, which seems to report truncated numbers.
Note: Put the more recent commit last.