Retrieving password when the password stored as a hash value

Question

Can users request that their password be emailed to themselves if the password is stored as a hash value?

Is there any way to convert a hash value to the clear text value with the proper information (& what information would you need)?

If a user has the same password hash value stored on two sites, would their password be the same for both sites?

Answer 1

If you're only storing a hash of the password, then no. ...and you should only be storing a properly-salted hash of their password, anyway.

Password reset mechanisms are the proper alternative.

Answer 2

Hashed passwords cannot be retrieved in general (this depends on the hashing function, secure hashes cannot be retrieved). If they have the same hash on two sites, they could have the same password, this depends on the hash salt used by the sites, what method etc.

If your password is securely stored in a good hashing system, a provider should never be able to email you your password, you must reset your password if you forget it.

Answer 3

In short, no. With most hashing algorithms, you can have multiple inputs with the same output. It is often better to offer a password reset option.

Answer 4

There are different types of hashing algorithms. Some are more secure than others. MD5 is a popular, but insecure one. The SHA-family is another more secure set of algorithms.

By definition, a hash is a one way function. It can not be reversed.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sha-1

Answer 5

If there was a simple way to recover the clear-text password, there would be no point in hashing the passwords to begin with. At that point you might as well just base64 or ROT13 them. (don't do that!)

As others mentioned, use other password recovery methods. There really is never a good reason to have access to clear-text passwords.

If the hash at two sites is the same, the user most likely has the same password at both. Not 100% guaranteed however, there could be a hash collision, but that is hugely improbable.

Answer 6

There is no way to reverse the commonly used hashes. They can be bruteforced (trying every single possible password) or you can use a wordlist (using a list of commonly used passwords) in combination to brute force to speed it up some, but it is still a very slow and CPU intensive process.

The best way, which many sites use, it to create a "Password Reset" button where you enter your username and email, and if they match, it sends you a random password and gives you a link to the login page and you can login with your random password and change your password.

Answer 7

To do this you must have a model with the fields:

Hashed_password
Salt

And you need to know the method user to hash the password( Here I use SHA1) Then you can define in your controller:

def self.encrypted_password(password, salt)
   string_to_hash = password + "wibble" + salt
   Digest::SHA1.hexdigest(string_to_hash)
end

Next you can compare:

user.Hashed_password == encrypted_password(password, user.salt)

True means that "password" is the password for the user "user"

Answer 8

The general idea behind storing a hash of a password is to ensure the passwords are secure...even from those who have access to the database. Trust is never implicit. A hash is a one-way algorithm, so there is no way to derive the original password from a hashcode. Usually, when a user needs to recover their password that was stored as a hash, you should ask them their secret question, and either email them their temporary password, or email them a temporary link where they can change their password. This ensures that the password is never stored clear text, and is secure from all prying eyes, even those who might be assumed to be trustworthy.