The anser was a problem with our domain host WP Engine, who tricks spiders into ignoring pure numeric strings at the end of page URL's. Pertains specifically to:
- Googlebot (Google's spider)
- Slurp! (Yahoo's spider)
- BingBot (Bing's spider)
- Facebook OG/Debugger
For example, the following URL:
http://www.website.com/profile/12345
Will be interpreted to these bots as:
http://www.website.com/profile
However, if the string is non-numeric the bots will recognize it. This is done for caching purposes. But again, this pertains only to WP Engine and a few other hosting providers.