Thank you all for your help! You pointed me in the right direction, here's how I got my code to work with BeautifulSoup. I noticed that all the data I wanted was under a class called "value chg" followed by and my data is always the 3rd and 5th element in that search, so this is what I did:
from BeautifulSoup import BeautifulSoup
import urllib
content = urllib.urlopen(url).read()
soup = BeautifulSoup(''.join(content))
td_list = soup.findAll('td', {'class':'value chg'} )
mon3 = td_list[2].text.encode('ascii','ignore')
yr1 = td_list[4].text.encode('ascii','ignore')
Again, "content" is the HTML that I've downloaded..