I figured it out: I updated my SubTotal Control Source to omit non-zeros or nulls:
=Nz(DLookUp("[Services Total]","[Services Total]","[WOrderID] = '" & [txtWOrderID] & "'"),0)+Nz(DLookUp("[Parts Total]","[Parts Total]","[WOrderID] = '" & [txtWOrderID] & "'"),0)
Simple problem that broke my whole database...