There does not seem to be any evidence of Google using the value of a title
attribute in an a
element at all. The blog entry Does Adding A Title On My Links Help With Ranking? says this rather emphatically. My quick test (with a quoted string of words that appears in a title
attribute in a site of mine that has been in Google indexes for a long time) gave no hit, even though both the linking and linked page can easily be found using key words that appear in their content.
It is not likely that this will change, since title
attributes could easily be targets for spamdexing if search engines used them. Moreover, the popularity of such attributes in authoring is decreasing; authors tend to use “CSS tooltips” instead.
So the title
attribute in a
is irrelevant to search engines. You need to formulate the link text so that it is meaningful when taken in isolation.