I would use the inline syntax in VB.NETonly with short and simple conditions. Otherwise it makes the code less readable and more error-prone.
Try this:
For Each computer In compArray
If compArray(i) <> Computers.GetKey(i) Then
notpresentList.Add(Computers.GetKey(i))
Else
Dim comp = Computers.GetByIndex(i)
If comp = 0 Then
disabledList.Add(Computers.GetKey(i))
ElseIf comp = 1 Then
enabledList.Add(Computers.GetKey(i))
ElseIf comp = 2 Then
unknownList.Add(Computers.GetKey(i))
Else ' added this to show you that this case is not covered yet
Throw New NotSupportedException
End If
End If
i += 1
Next