ASIHTTPRequest and AFNetworking in 2013. What to choose? [closed]

Question

Closed. This question is opinion-based. It is not currently accepting answers.

---

Want to improve this question? Update the question so it can be answered with facts and citations by editing this post.

Closed 8 years ago.

Improve this question

I'm in the beginning of developing a large iOS project which is heavily network based. And I'm interested what framework should I choose now. I see a lot of posts on SO about it: ASIHTTPRequest vs AFNetworking framework and etc. But they are all old. And I also read this:http://allseeing-i.com/%5Brequest_release%5D; After giving it a lot of thought over the last few weeks, I’ve decided that I’m not going to continue working on ASIHTTPRequest in future. it was written back in 2011. So as I understood ASIHTTPRequest is obsolete? I haven't a lot of experience in iOS. So I'm interested what is a modern state of things. What is better - ASIHTTPRequest or AFNetworking? I'm interested in the next criteria:

1. JSON performance (integration with NSJSONSerialization)
2. Richness of API (uploading files,http queries)
3. Simplicity
4. iOS 6 and future iOS 7 integration

Answer 1

I will keep this short to not belabour the point. I have done many iOS apps with both ASIHTTP and AFNetworking.

I now no longer use ASIHTTPRequest for the following reasons:

• It is a dormant project, and nobody is working on it or maintaining it.
• It has not been upgraded to use ARC (Automatic reference counting), so it becomes clear you are embedding legacy code when you have to have compilor switches of -fno-objc-arc to make it build.
• It has not been updated to make use of blocks which brings the development back to somewhat older design patterns.

AFNetworking is a good choice for majority of your criteria, for the following reasons:

• AFNetworking is not dormant, and is actively being contributed to. (this is in a good place to take over from ASIHTTPRequest if it added more file handling)
• JSON Performance - it does integrate with NSJSONSerialization and deserialize json REST requests automatically for you.
• API is very clean and easy to use (makes use of blocks, so your code will be cleaner also) But, i would recommend using something else for file downloads and uploads, don't know a good standard solution for this yet.
• Simplicity, yes, very simple.
• No issues with using it for iOS 6 and 7, have just used it recently for a project and it's iOS 7 ready.

Hope this helps.

Answer 2

I preferred ASIHTTPRequest over AFNetworking for below reasons.

• If your application does heavy upload operation such as multiple images/videos.
• It does direct streaming of files from your disk, we just have to specify the path of the file and initiate the upload process.
• It does bandwidth throttling.
• It have multiple delegates giving callbacks on the upload progress status.
• Has well managed queues that handle multiple requests.